Health + Beauty

The Gwynnie Bee Experiment

I have been going back and forth on signing up for Gwynnie Bee for months now, and a few weeks ago I finally signed up. With a free month to try it out, what is there to lose besides some self esteem when none of the clothes fit? Hat tip to my friends Emmie and Kate for inspiring me to finally go for it!

Side note: this is not a sponsored post, but –> this link right here is a ‘refer-a-friend’ link, which means that if you happen to sign up for the service by using my link, I get an extra piece of clothing to try — no shenanigans, just more opportunities for me to try ALL THE THINGS!

If you don’t already know what Gwynnie Bee is, it’s a clothing rental subscription service, catering to women between the sizes of 10 – 32. Think, Netflix for clothes. They have many different designers and styles, and there is even an option that if you love an item you can purchase it at a discounted price. They have several different levels of subscriptions but it starts at $35 for one piece of clothing out at a time, with unlimited exchanges and free shipping both ways.

Now, I rarely buy new clothes for mainly two reasons:

1. I’m just not that fancy,

2. “I don’t want to buy new clothes while I’m losing weight,” has been my mantra for far longer than I care to admit.

The turning point? I realized I dress like a stereotypical frumpy-old-lady-office-worker, and if I really do hope to trick a man into marrying me catch a man’s eye, I should probably start to care a little bit more about how I present myself to the world. I’m also really tired of black slacks and figured I should try some dresses. Reason number two still stands though, so I decided I’d try the rental route!

I was super excited to get my first box of three items (dresses!) a couple weeks ago and I immediately tried on the first dress thinking I was going to look fabulous just like the model on the website… no. I was suddenly reminded why I don’t wear dresses and instead hide in black slacks and blousy tops and cardigans. It was such a horrible hit to my self-esteem that I didn’t even try on the other two dresses. Instead I hung all three in the closet for  A WEEK trying to get up the courage to try them on and fighting the urge to send them all back and cancel the whole thing.

Luckily I gave myself another shot, and the results weren’t as horrible as I had originally thought (also, 4 inch heels fix any outfit).

Dress 1: Jessica Howard / Belted Fit & Flare Dress with Cap Sleeves

Jessica Howard Fit and Flare

Let’s ignore the fact that I need to figure out a different place to take photos, and I’m completely squishing my left boob to take the photo (haha!).

The dress isn’t as terrible as I had originally thought, but it’s just not something I was comfortable in. It fit fine, but was rather heavy and had an odd all-over pattern that I had originally thought was black herringbone (from the website photo) but is actually a bunch of navy blue mis-shaped ‘O’s (there is now a photo of the pattern on the website).

I am definitely very top-heavy, but this dress just made me feel/look extra top-heavy and that’s something I like to try to minimize! So back in the return bag it went.

Dress 2: Flutter / Happy Daisy Printed Dress

Flutter Happy Daisy Dress

I actually thought this dress was super cute and flattering from the front and I loved the bodice pattern and colors!


Flutter Happy Dress Bodice

I do not have cone-shaped-80’s-Madonna-boobs, and there was no way I could manipulate the fabric to make it look any different…bummer.

But this does remind me of the one time I went to get a bra-fitting at the only store in town (at the time) that catered to larger chested women. It was this hole-in-the-wall store in a dirty old strip mall, but was owned by a lovely elderly woman. She wasn’t afraid of getting handsy in the dressing room to make sure I got the best fit, and she convinced me to buy this expensive contraption of a bra that I felt great in, but apparently made me look a lot pointy. The first time my BFF saw me wearing it, she made fun of me for 2 hours straight. Needless to say, I never wore the bra again. All I can say is, thank goodness for Lane Bryant and Cacique!

Anyway… super cute dress, but I obviously sent it back unworn. Maybe I’ll get it in a smaller size once I’ve lost some weight and see if it fits differently.

Dress 3: Triste / Animal Print Shawl Collar Dress

Triste Animal PrintThis dress was by far my favorite! I wasn’t sure I would like the animal print, but I actually loved it! There’s a light blue accent color throughout the print and a matching blue string belt. It also perfectly covered my chest and I thought it was an extremely flattering cut.

Triste animal print bodice open

But then as I was admiring myself in the mirror I noticed something…

Triste Animal Print bodice snap

That right there is the snap that is supposed to close the bodice fabric, and it is almost exactly where my nipple is!

So I pulled the fabric together and tried to snap it closed…

Triste animal print closed bodice

Not so pretty anymore and it also created a giant gaping hole of “hey, everyone look into my shirt!”… and then I breathed in and it popped back open.

Boo. I even considered for a moment that the snap is pretty small and not noticeable from afar, so I could/might/maybe be able to wear it un-snapped and no one would know. Except that I’m the person who always self-consciously brings attention to the flaws of an outfit by constantly playing with/touching the defect… and I really don’t want to get written up by HR for this one!

So sadly, this went back unworn as well but it is definitely one I will re-closet in a smaller size once I get there (assuming I keep using the service!!).

Over-all I think I had a really good initial experience (forgetting about my first week freak out) and I’m happy with the sizes I chose (I’m between sizes so I sized up) even though nothing fit quite well enough for me to comfortably wear out in public. I blame my ancestors and their giant-chest genes.

If you’d like to check out the service, here’s my link again (please and thank you): Gwynnie Bee Refer-A-Friend

I also just got my second box with two tops and a skirt, and I’m excited to try them on… cross your fingers for me!!

Are you using Gwynnie Bee now, or have you tried it before? Do you have other methods for saving money on clothes while losing weight? I’d love to hear your advice!
Previous Post - Dear Office Crush Wearing Dresses Makes You Lose Weight - Next Post

You Might Also Like


  • Reply Denise July 14, 2014 at 7:23 pm

    OK. I think we had nearly the same point bra fitted by a handsy little old lady experience! Mine was so bad even my brothers called it my Madonna bra. And I kept wearing it. Hmmmm….

    • Reply Tiffany July 16, 2014 at 11:23 am

      Haha! You know, it makes me feel better that I’m not the only one! I still have the bra somewhere. After I wrote this post I started thinking that I should wear it again sometime just for fun. If Joan on ‘Mad Men’ can do it, why can’t we?!

  • Reply Kate July 15, 2014 at 9:40 am

    Bummer about that second dress because it is SO good on you. Same with number 3. I’m glad you ended up giving them a try despite that first hiccup. I had the same fears going in, like what if I just don’t have the right body type to use this service but after some experimenting it all worked out. Can’t wait to see what you got next!

    • Reply Tiffany July 16, 2014 at 11:31 am

      Yeah, I’ll definitely be re-closeting the 2nd and 3rd ones again later. Thank you! There’s now so much stuff in my closet that I’m sooo looking forward to trying that I’m pretty much guaranteed to keep paying for the service. Well played Gwynnie Bee, well played! :)

    Leave a Reply